Digital Britain - Who's Paying for it?
19/06/2009
It’s here at last – the 245-page report setting out the Government’s vision for the communications industry in the 21st century. Fundamentally it deals with providing broadband for all – bridging the digital divide – and securing the future of public service broadcasting in this country.
The proposals on broadband seem fair enough. People need access to it for all kinds of reasons these days and it seems unfair to prejudice people because of their postcode. Even though the speeds being discussed are hardly likely to send most consumers rushing to watch on-line television channels.
But I can’t say the same for the rest. Having spent several years working at the BBC I’d be the first to make my many moans and complaints heard. But I’d also be quick to recognise that the BBC is a world-renowned centre for excellence. I’ve worked in a multitude of different markets and nowhere have I found a craft base to compare with the Beeb.
And surprisingly I also think it provides excellent value for money. Now, granted, if we were starting from here we probably wouldn’t re-invent a tax funded monolith like the BBC. But we aren’t starting from here and I think tinkering with it now will set a dangerous precedent for years to come.
But that’s not my main gripe with ‘Digital Britain’. What bothers me is the unimaginative approach to the current funding crisis. Instead of looking creatively at future models all we’re really doing is looking backwards at a tax/revenue model. And this I think has two main consequences. It creates a dependency model for news providers. If there’s 130 million pounds worth of BBC revenue up for grabs that beats having to work it out for yourself.
And critically because they’re not paying directly for the services provided it also takes consumer choice out of the equation. Instead of the Government paying for a service regardless of need shouldn’t we be looking at demand driven models. Surely one thing we know about the digital age is that a proliferation of channels doesn’t necessarily mean more choice.
So two cheers for the report in terms of infrastructure – or as the Lord Carter would say the ‘pipes’. But I would have loved to see some more creative commercial thinking with regard to news provision. Mind you I suspect we’re going to see many months of ‘consultation’ before any of this truly sees the light of day.
Stephen Horn
CEO, WebsEdge
Comments
Blog
-
New Localism Bill - what does it mean to you?
So now we know. The long-awaited Localism Bill has finally been published, alongside the details for local government funding. -
An email worth opening….
Guest blog by Helen Burkhalter, LG Challenge Contest 2010 -
Divided by a common language
-
Is Content Really King anymore?
Or is it really now just another commodity? -
Council Worker of the Year Award 2010 Winners!!
-
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Lifetime Service
Find out more about the finalists in the Lifetime Service category. -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Team
Find out more about the Team of the Year Category -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Community Engagement
Find out more about the finalists in the Community Engagement Category. -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Working with Young People
Find out more about the finalists in the Working with Young People category. -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Green Award
Find out more about the finalists in the Green Award category. -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010: Bravery
Find out more about the finalists in the Bravery category. -
Voting has now ended
Council of the Year Awards 2010 -
Challenge 2: Waverley Borough Council and Surrey County Council
The Town that Wants a Team -
Challenge 1: Sent to Coventry
Blog by Tracey O'Halloran, Host of the Local Government Challenge -
First Challenge - Votes and Voices has finished!
Coventry challenge a huge success as council takes forward campaign ideas -
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2010
NOMINATIONS NOW OPEN! -
Local Government Challenge Finalists Announced
-
Council Worker of the Year Awards 2009
WINNERS HAVE BEEN ANNOUNCED! -
What gets you up in the morning?
So it's over for another year, council worker of the year awards. The votes have been counted, the champagne has been drunk... -
Digital Britain - Who's Paying for it?
It's here at last - the 245-page report setting out the Government's vision for the communications industry in the 21st century. -
What shape is your recession?
I'm in Washington at the moment and all the talk is about green shoots. Like in London everyone is keen to put the bad news behind us and move on... -
Local Government Heroes One and All
I know local authorities often have a bad press. Now I know this is nothing new but...
Discussion
-
What a difference a year makes.
Tell us - what were your highs and lows of 2010? How are you feeling about 2011? What are your priorities for the year ahead? -
Election Special – You ask the questions!
Tell us at the Local Government Channel the real questions you want put to Labour, the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats. -
Women missing out on top jobs?
Share your thoughts... -
Welcome to the New website!
Each week from now the Local Government Channel team will be asking you to participate...
Thank you. You comment has been sent and will be reviewed for posting shortly.
Sorry, some errors occured. Please review the form below and try again.